The SOCIETY Newsletter #112

From Ghosts to Standards

How Bogey, Par, Birdie—and the Ball Itself—Redefined Golf

Golf’s scoring language feels timeless, but it is anything but. Bogey, par, and birdie did not emerge as a tidy system, nor were they invented at once. They arrived in response to a changing game, one shaped as much by equipment technology as by culture, competition, and golf course architecture.

To understand why golf counts the way it does, you must first understand how the ball learned to fly.

⸻

Bogey and the Age of the Gutty

For a little more than half of the 19th century, golf was played with the gutta-percha ball, or gutty—a solid, durable sphere molded from tree sap. The gutty was revolutionary in replacing the semi- fragile feathery (a ball made of leather stuffed with goose feathers), but it imposed clear limits. It favored low, running shots. It punished imperfect strikes.

This was a game of restraint.

It was in this environment that bogey emerged. Borrowed from the popular music-hall tune The Bogey Man, golfers imagined an unseen opponent by the name of Colonel Bogey who represented the score a good, steady player ought to make. Bogey was not perfection. It was competence. It fit a game where brilliance was rare and survival was success. 

For our golfing ancestors, “bogey” wasn’t the word of dread that it is today. It was similar to, but not quite the same as the word “par” that we use today.

⸻

The Haskell Ball and the Collapse of the Old Standard

Everything changed at the turn of the 20th century.

In 1898, Coburn Haskell introduced a rubber-cored, wound golf ball that would permanently alter golf’s trajectory. The Haskell ball flew higher, carried farther, and responded predictably to clean contact. Hazards that once dictated strategy could now be challenged or even ignored. Greens were no longer approached cautiously along the ground; they were attacked from the air.

The gutty-era standard of bogey no longer made sense.

Bogey, once a respectable target, suddenly felt conservative. Golfers were reaching holes in fewer strokes with regularity. Excellence was no longer accidental…it was repeatable. The game demanded a new reference point.

⸻

Par: Architecture, Expectation, and Expertise

That new reference was par.

Borrowed from finance, where it signified a fixed standard, par entered golf as the score an expert golfer should make under normal conditions. It reflected not just player ability, but architectural intent. Distance, hazard placement, and angles of attack could now be calibrated to an ideal outcome.

Par did not replace bogey by accident. It replaced it because the game had outgrown it.

As the Haskell ball stretched the course, par provided a way to organize ambition. Holes could be designed with purpose. Strategy could be intentional rather than defensive. Golf began to align its language with its aspirations.

⸻

Birdie: Celebrating the New Possible

With par established, golf needed a way to describe what happened when a player exceeded expectation.

Enter birdie.

Born in early-20th-century American slang, birdie described a score one stroke better than par—a “bird of a shot” followed by a holed putt. The term stuck because it captured something new: the joy of excellence in a game that now allowed it.

In the gutty era, such moments were anomalies. In the Haskell era, they became achievable goals. Scoring language expanded upward because the ceiling of performance had been raised.

Eagles and albatrosses would follow, but birdie remained the soul of modern scoring—the moment when preparation, equipment, and nerve aligned.

⸻

Bogey Reconsidered

In this new hierarchy, bogey was redefined.

What had once been the central benchmark became a measure of deviation - one stroke over par. Colonel Bogey, the steady ghost of the gutty age, had been overtaken by progress. Golf no longer chased him. It measured itself against something higher.

⸻

Language Follows the Ball

By the early 20th century, golf’s scoring system had settled into its modern form—not because administrators decreed it, but because technology forced clarity.

 • The gutty demanded restraint and made bogey logical

 • The Haskell ball rewarded precision and made par necessary

 • Greater consistency made birdie meaningful

Golf’s evolution from ground game to aerial game required a rethink of expectation, and expectation demanded new words.

The scorecard, like the ball, had evolved.

And every time we circle a birdie or grimace at a bogey, we are still responding to a moment—more than a century ago—when the game learned how to fly.

*Here is a delightful historical twist on this story. As I was researching it, I came across two long lost terms for golf scoring. Squawks and Buzzards!!!!

A "squawk" is a hole made in ten, while the term "buzzard" is applied to twelve or more.

The Modern Game

A couple of years back Bryson DeChambeau was lambasted for saying that Augusta National was really a Par 67. The media and the fans pounced, but in reality, whether it was intended or not, Bryson’s comments have historical merit.

Par, since its inception, has never been stagnant, it has always reflected the technology and ability of golfers. When Oakmont opened it’s doors in the early 1900s it was considered a par 80- that number dropped (evolved) over the decades.

PGA Tour fans have recently started to lament winning scores twenty plus under par, but the solution if you care about such things, is a historical one…change par. What I find amusing is that we are fine elongating par threes to 300 yards, we are fine making par fours over 500 yards, but somehow it’s heresy to have tour players compete on a course that changes its par from 72 to 68 or 69. Par has always been malleable- it’s never been fixed. Some will say the rollback will solve these issues, but if history teaches us anything- technology always finds a way.

Celebrate the First Major of the Year

Antiquity Golf Co is celebrating the Masters Tournament by celebrating one of the most important corners of the golf universe during the second week of April.

The stitch work on the hat is amazing. If you are interested in purchasing some gear check them out at www.antiquitygolfco.com 

And finally we do have a couple of prototype Large Apple Watch Bands. You can view this watch band on the website, but will need to reach out to me if you have an interest.

THE SOCIETY GOLF AUCTION

Just a reminder that we have our annual Society of Golf Historians Auction coming up in March. We now have thirty golf experiences to bid on- including a round with me at the 21 Golf Club’s brand new MacKenzie Course.

Stay tuned.

Society Golf Outings

Are you a member of the Society of Golf Historians? One reason to consider joining us is for our historical golf outings. This past January I hosted a lot of you at my club, Belleair CC.

This Fall we will be hosting a small outing at Oak Hill Country Club- home of the 3 US Opens, 4 PGA Championships, 2 US Amateurs and a Ryder Cup. We will play golf and then break bread and learn more about the history of this magnificent golf club.

Stay tuned for more information.