The SOCIETY Newsletter #81

Scottie Scheffler: The Next Tiger? Or the Next Hogan & Nelson?

The summer of 2025 belongs to Scottie Scheffler.

With unshakable consistency, quiet composure, and a résumé that keeps expanding by the week, it’s no surprise that fans and pundits alike have begun to whisper the ultimate comparison: Is this the next Tiger Woods?

But is that really the right comparison?

While Scheffler’s recent dominance may stir echoes of Tiger’s early 2000s supremacy, a closer look—at his path, personality, and precision—reveals a different lineage. Not one of seismic cultural disruption like Tiger Woods, but one rooted in golfing tradition, discipline, and humility.

To find a more fitting comparison, we may need to look a little further back—toward Ben Hogan and Byron Nelson.

Scheffler and the Tiger Talk

The Tiger comparisons are understandable. Scheffler is the world’s No. 1. He’s racking up wins with clinical precision. His strokes gained numbers are staggering. His short game is quietly elite. And now, yes—he can putt.

But a few key differences separate the two.

First, Tiger transcended the game. He wasn’t just dominant—he was a cultural phenomenon. He revolutionized athleticism in golf, reshaped the TV audience, and brought the sport to an entirely new demographic. His dominance was as much sociological as it was statistical.

Second, Tiger’s path through a golf course was different. Early on, he separated himself with sheer power—outdriving the field by 30+ yards. His driving could be erratic at times, but his ability to recover from impossible situations was superhuman. Tiger made chaos look calculated.

Scheffler, on the other hand, wins with structure. His dominance is quieter—more workmanlike. He doesn’t overpower a golf course; he dissects it. He doesn’t thrive on chaos; he avoids it. He strategizes, executes, and rarely strays.

Which is why comparisons to Woods might miss the mark.

To understand Scheffler, it might be more accurate to consider the dual legacy of Hogan and Nelson. 

⸻

Scheffler as Hogan and Nelson — Two Sides of a Great Coin

Scottie’s game, demeanor, and outlook feel like a fusion of Ben Hogan’s relentless precision and Byron Nelson’s serene consistency and personal humility.

 • Like Hogan, Scheffler’s success is built on elite ball-striking. He plays with an engineer’s mind—his swing, while not textbook, is ruthlessly repeatable. Hogan wasn’t known for flair, but for control. He studied the game with an intensity that bordered on obsession, and bent it to his will. So does Scottie.

 • Like Nelson, Scheffler is emotionally unshakable. There’s a calmness to his presence, a quiet dignity that mirrors Nelson’s legendary 1945 season. Scheffler may never win 11 straight events—but week in, week out, he contends without complaint, without collapse.

And like Nelson, Scheffler sees the game as a means, not an end. For Nelson, it was a path to his ranch. For Scheffler, it’s a platform grounded in faith and family. Both men were fiercely competitive—but uninterested in the glamour. They played because they loved to compete, not because they loved the spotlight.

They were Texans. So is Scheffler.

They let their golf speak for itself. So does Scheffler.

They had a clear sense of self outside the ropes. So does Scheffler.

⸻

What History Tells Us

If we’re lucky, history doesn’t repeat—but it does rhyme.

Tiger Woods was a singular phenomenon. He changed golf’s trajectory forever.

Scottie Scheffler isn’t trying to change the game—he’s trying to master it. His wins aren’t loud—they’re inevitable. His presence isn’t electric—it’s surgical.

He’s not the next Tiger.

He might be something rarer:

A modern blend of Hogan’s grit and Nelson’s grace.  

And that, in its own way, is just as historic.

⸻

Final Thought:

Let’s hope Scottie doesn’t walk away from the game early, like Byron Nelson did in his prime. But if he ever did, none of us would be surprised. Because for Scottie Scheffler, golf isn’t the whole story—it’s just one chapter in a life well played.

100 OBJECTS THAT CHANGED THE GAME OF GOLF: THE AMANA VIP GOLF HAT

A very short docupod on the golf hat that literally changed the face of golf. Give me seven minutes of your time, I promise you will enjoy it. Click the link below to listen for free.

THANK YOU!

Thank you for taking the time to read our newsletter. If you have ideas for future newsletters, please let me know.